What is constitutional morality?
Constitutional morality.

Constitutional morality is the concept that primarily ascertains the deep and humble abiding force towards constitutional values. It also refers to the positive aspects of the Constitution along with its substantive teachings. The concept of constitutional morality promotes the implementation of primary ideals adopted by the Constitution.

This article talks about the principle of Constitutional Morality, which has been highly used and interpreted by the Supreme Court in various judgements in the past decade.

Constitutional Ideals Being Part of Constitutional Morality

The elements of constitutional morality are the supreme ideals and important concepts mentioned in the Constitution and thus include the rule of law, the procedure established by law, due process of law, social justice, individual liberty, right to equality, right to freedom and the Preamble.

Bare Act PDFs

Analysis of the Concept of Constitutional Morality

The term constitutional morality has not been succinctly (clearly) defined in either the Constitution or by the Supreme Court. Thus, it keeps the principle open to a wide range of interpretation and analysis.

The idea of constitutional morality was discussed by Dr BR Ambedkar (mentioning the phrase first used by George Grote) during his speech, ‘The Draft Constitution‘, as the principle promoting a cordial liaison between the governing and the governed. According to him, the state should run in an unbiased manner, thus, ending any form of social injustice, and all this can be done with the avid implementation of the principles of constitutional morality.

Cordial: friendly.
Liaison: communication or cooperation which facilitates a close working relationship between people or organisations.

The idea of constitutional morality also goes against the idea of popular morality or authoritarian view. Although the Supreme Court in Navtej Singh Johar vs Union of India, while citing the principle of constitutional morality, said that ‘majoritarian views, popular morality cannot dictate constitutional rights‘.

Criticism of the Concept of Constitutional Morality

As the term constitutional morality gravely hints at the idea of strict implementation of constitutional principles, thus, sometimes it is considered to be a source of judicial overreach and goes against the principle of separation of power.

It has been criticised that Supreme Court often enters the arena of legislature and functions beyond its assigned power while implementing the idea of constitutional morality. The Supreme Court, in its Sabrimala judgement as well as the present Attorney General of India, K.K. Venugopal called the doctrine of constitutional morality a dangerous doctrine.

Cases Mentioning the Principle of Constitutional Morality

The principle of constitutional morality has been vividly used in the Supreme Court judgements after 2014.

These are some prominent cases in which the term constitutional morality has been used and interpreted by the Supreme Court:

  • Manoj Narula vs Union of India
  • Indian Young Lawyers Association vs the State of Kerala
  • Navtej Singh Johar vs Union of India
  • Sri Subhas Bhattacharjee vs the State of Tripura
  • The Trustee vs the State of Kerala, etc.

Conclusion

It can be said that the principle of constitutional morality is a highly debated principle in India.

A limited and within-the-scope implementation of constitutional morality can produce highly beneficial results upholding the essence of justice. On the other hand, it has a great capacity to be misused as well.

Thus, we can conclude that a clear definition of the term and a firm boundary limit of its use are the basic requirements at present.

Read Next:
1.
What Is the Mini Constitution of India and Changes It Added
2. 10 Constitutional Provisions That Guarantee Independence of Supreme Court

ABOUT OUR AUTHOR
Author Ruchi Mahil WritingLaw
This article is written by Ruchi Mahil, a law student from Himachal Pradesh University. She is a law enthusiast who loves to read and write about various legal happenings in India and across the world.
WritingLaw » Law Notes » What Is Constitutional Morality – Analysis, Criticism and Cases Law Study Material
If you are a regular reader, please consider buying the Law PDFs and MCQ Tests. You will love them. You may also support us with any amount you like. Thank You.